Pillinger Works

Luck vs. Decision

BeginnerB-049
Ready to move forward?

You can explore the materials without registering, but with a free account you can track your progress and earn rewards along the way. By the end of your learning journey, you can have the knowledge you need to become a profitable Trader!

Join →

Luck vs. Decision

A trade outcome contains both information about our decision and an element of randomness. A good decision can lose money, and a poor decision can make money.

Decision Quality

We should evaluate the decision using the information and rules available at the time, not only the final price outcome. This is especially important when the sample size is small.

Why This Matters

If we confuse luck with skill, a lucky result can reinforce a bad process. Conversely, a normal losing outcome can cause us to abandon a sound process prematurely.

A professional trading record therefore needs more than profit and loss. We also need information about the setup, risk, execution, and rule adherence.

Key Terms

Luck, decision quality, randomness, outcome, process, sample size.

Knowledge Check

  1. Can a good decision lose money?
  2. Why can a lucky profit reinforce a bad process?
  3. What should we evaluate besides the final P&L?